Floating Decks vs Traditional Decks: Design & Durability in Jacksonville, FL

If you’re planning to upgrade your outdoor space in Jacksonville, FL, one key decision you’ll face is whether to install a Floating Deck or a Traditional Deck. Each option has its own set of features, benefits, and costs. Your choice will depend on your budget, space, and long-term goals for your property.

Floating decks offer flexibility and cost savings, while traditional decks provide stability, height, and increased home value. This guide will break down the differences, benefits, and ideal uses of both deck types, helping you choose the option that fits your home’s unique needs.

What is a Floating Deck?

A floating deck is a freestanding deck that does not attach to your house or any other structure. Instead, it sits on deck blocks or small footings that support the weight of the deck. Since it’s not connected to a home, it gives you the freedom to place it anywhere in your yard.

Benefits of Floating Decks in Jacksonville, FL

• Flexible Placement: Can be placed anywhere in your yard, unlike traditional decks which are attached to a house.
• No Permits Required: This option saves time and money, as most areas in Jacksonville, FL, don’t require permits for floating decks.
• Cost-Effective: Uses fewer materials and requires less labor, which lowers the overall cost.
• Tree-Friendly Design: This avoids damage to existing tree roots, making it ideal for areas with mature landscaping.

Best Uses for Floating Decks in Jacksonville, FL

• Backyard Patios: Perfect for creating a small, cozy outdoor retreat in any part of your yard.
• Poolside Lounging: Great for building a space to relax by the pool.
• Garden Spaces: Ideal for placing in a garden as a quiet spot to relax or enjoy the view.
• Hard-to-Reach Areas: Works well in places where the ground is uneven or where digging footings isn’t possible.

If you’re looking for a cost-effective, fast-to-install deck that can be placed anywhere on your property, a floating deck might be the right choice. Call (904) 842-3929 for a free quote on a custom floating deck in Jacksonville, FL.

What is a Traditional Deck?

A traditional deck is attached directly to your home using a ledger board for support and stability. It acts as an extension of your living space and is often built higher off the ground than a floating deck. Due to their attachment to the home and their impact on the property’s structure, traditional decks require permits and inspections.

Benefits of Traditional Decks in Jacksonville, FL

1. Increases Property Value

Traditional decks are considered permanent additions to a home, similar to adding a new room or an extension. Because they are attached to the house, they are seen as a structural upgrade, which can increase the resale value of the property. Buyers are more likely to pay a premium for a home with a well-built, attached deck.

2. Offers Greater Stability

Unlike floating decks, traditional decks are firmly attached to your home using a ledger board. They also sit on concrete footings for extra support, ensuring the deck remains secure and stable. This makes traditional decks more resistant to movement, shifting, or damage from strong winds.

3. Customizable Design Options

Traditional decks are fully customizable. You can design a deck with:

• Multi-level platforms for a unique layout.
• Built-in seating for extra convenience.
• Custom railings with wood, metal, or glass materials.
• Stairs that provide access to the yard below.
  This flexibility in design allows you to create a space that matches your home’s style and your outdoor needs.

4. Elevated Height Options

Traditional decks can be elevated to create a second-story balcony or a high outdoor entertainment area. Elevated decks are great for homes with water views or scenic backyards. You can also add under-deck storage or a shaded patio below.

5. Perfect for Hosting and Entertaining

Traditional decks provide a larger, more stable surface that can handle heavy foot traffic, making them perfect for BBQs, family gatherings, and outdoor parties. Their ability to support heavy furniture, grills, and even hot tubs gives them an edge over floating decks.

Best Uses for Traditional Decks in Jacksonville, FL

• Second-Story Balconies: Ideal for properties near waterfronts or scenic landscapes where you want to take advantage of the view.
• Multi-Level Decks: These decks are useful for properties with sloped or uneven ground. They connect different areas of the yard while providing visual interest.
• Home Extensions: You can expand your living space by connecting the deck to indoor areas like a kitchen, dining room, or living room.
• Entertaining Areas: Traditional decks are ideal for parties, grilling, and outdoor dining with family and friends.

Key Differences Between Floating Decks and Traditional Decks

This table makes it clear that floating decks are the best option for flexibility and affordability, while traditional decks are the better choice for long-term stability and resale value.

Advantages and Disadvantages of Floating Decks

Advantages of Floating Decks in Jacksonville, FL

1. No Permits Required

One of the biggest benefits of a floating deck is that it does not require a building permit in most areas of Jacksonville, FL. Since it’s a freestanding structure, it is not considered a permanent home addition, allowing you to skip the lengthy permit process. This saves time and money.

2. Cost-Effective

Since floating decks don’t require ledger boards, footings, or professional labor, they are significantly cheaper to build. The main materials you’ll need are deck blocks, beams, and deck boards. You can choose between wood, composite, or PVC materials based on your budget. Labor costs are also lower since floating decks are simpler to construct.

3. Simple Installation

Building a floating deck is quick and straightforward. It involves placing deck blocks on the leveled ground and then attaching beams, joists, and deck boards. The entire process can be completed in just a few days, especially when handled by a professional deck contractor.

4. Flexible Placement

Floating decks don’t have to be attached to your home. They can be placed in the middle of your yard, next to a pool, or in a quiet corner for privacy. This flexibility allows for creative deck layouts and the opportunity to build in areas where a traditional deck wouldn’t be possible.

Disadvantages of Floating Decks

1. Limited Stability

Floating decks are freestanding, meaning they rely on deck blocks instead of being secured to the house. This can result in slight movement or shifting, especially in areas with heavy rain or high winds. Over time, you may need to adjust the deck to ensure it stays level.

2. Lower Weight Capacity

Unlike traditional decks, floating decks cannot support heavy loads like hot tubs, large grills, or outdoor kitchens. The load is spread across a series of deck blocks, so there are limits to what it can handle.

3. Closer to the Ground

Floating decks sit lower to the ground compared to traditional decks, which can limit your view. If you want a deck that offers scenic views of a waterfront or landscaped backyard, a traditional deck is the better option.

Advantages and Disadvantages of Traditional Decks

Advantages of Traditional Decks in Jacksonville, FL

1. Boosts Property Value

A traditional deck is seen as a permanent addition to your home. It increases property value and can attract buyers when you decide to sell your house. Since traditional decks are attached to the home, they are viewed as an upgrade similar to an extended living space. Homes with outdoor living spaces typically have higher resale values.

2. Elevated Views

Traditional decks can be built at any height, allowing homeowners to create second-story balconies or raised decks. This is especially useful for homes near water, wooded areas, or scenic backyards in Jacksonville, FL. Elevated decks also create shaded areas below that can be used for extra storage or a patio area.

3. Higher Load Capacity

Traditional decks are built with concrete footings, ledger boards, and support beams, allowing them to handle heavy loads. This makes it possible to place large furniture, hot tubs, fire pits, and outdoor kitchens on them. The extra support structure provides a strong and durable surface that won’t shift or sink.

4. Long-Term Durability

Traditional decks are designed to be a permanent, long-lasting addition to your home. The frame is made from pressure-treated wood, composite, or PVC materials to resist rot, moisture, and termites. With proper maintenance, a traditional deck can last 20+ years. The deck is also secured to the home’s structure, providing extra stability and protection against strong winds or heavy rain.

Disadvantages of Traditional Decks

1. Requires a Permit

A traditional deck is attached to a home and requires a building permit in Jacksonville, FL. Obtaining a permit involves submitting plans and waiting for approval, which can cause delays. Inspections are also required during construction to ensure the deck meets local building codes.

2. Longer Installation

Installing a traditional deck takes more time than a floating deck. The process involves attaching a ledger board, digging holes for concrete footings, and building the frame. Permits, inspections, and compliance with local codes add to the project timeline. If you’re looking for a faster option, a floating deck might be a better choice.

3. Higher Cost

Traditional decks have higher costs due to the need for more materials, labor, and permit fees. Labor costs increase because of the time it takes to install ledger boards, footings, and support beams. Materials like concrete, wood, or composite decking also add to the overall price. While traditional decks are more expensive, they offer better stability, higher load capacity, and increased home value.

Installation Process: Floating Deck vs Traditional Deck in Jacksonville, FL

Floating Deck Installation (4 Steps)

1. Ground Preparation

• The area where the deck will be placed is cleared of grass, roots, and debris.
• The ground is leveled to ensure the deck remains stable.

2. Place Deck Blocks

• Deck blocks (precast concrete) are spaced at equal points to act as the foundation.
• These blocks distribute the weight of the deck and eliminate the need for concrete footings.

3. Build the Frame

• Beams and joists are secured to the deck blocks to create the main frame.
• Joists are spaced equally to support the weight of the deck boards.

4. Install Decking Boards

• Decking boards (wood, composite, or PVC) are attached to the frame using screws or fasteners.
• The boards are laid flat and secured, creating a smooth deck surface.

Time to Install: 1-3 days (depending on deck size)
Permits Required?: No permits are required in most areas of Jacksonville, FL

Traditional Deck Installation (5 Steps)

1. Secure Ledger to Home

• The ledger board is attached directly to the home’s exterior wall.
• The ledger is secured using bolts to ensure it can handle heavy loads.

2. Install Footings

• Holes are dug for concrete footings to support the deck’s posts.
• The depth of the holes is based on local building codes, and concrete is poured to create a stable base.

3. Frame Construction

• Beams and joists are attached to the ledger board and footings, forming the deck’s support structure.
• The frame is checked for level and stability before proceeding.

4. Install Deck Boards

• Decking boards are attached to the frame using fasteners or screws.
• The boards are evenly spaced to allow for drainage and expansion.

5. Add Railings & Stairs

• For elevated decks, railings are installed for safety.
• Stairs are built to provide access to the ground level below.

Time to Install: 1-2 weeks (due to permits, inspections, and multi-step process)
Permits Required? Yes, permits are required in Jacksonville, FL

Cost Comparison of Floating vs Traditional Decks in Jacksonville, FL

Floating Deck Cost Summary

• Lower cost due to fewer materials and simpler installation.
• No permits, inspections, or heavy-duty footings are required.
• Great for DIY projects and fast installations.

Traditional Deck Cost Summary

• Higher cost due to the need for ledger boards, footings, and more materials.
• Permit fees and inspection fees are included in the cost.
• Requires skilled labor and more time to complete.

Materials Used for Floating and Traditional Decks

The type of material you choose for your deck affects its cost, durability, and maintenance needs. Floating and traditional decks can be built with a variety of materials, each offering unique benefits.

1. Wood Decks

• Cost: Affordable, upfront cost.
• Durability: Lasts 10-15 years with proper care.
• Maintenance: Requires staining, sealing, and protection from moisture and rot.
• Best Use: Works for both floating and traditional decks. It’s a great option if you want a natural look but are prepared for regular maintenance.

2. Composite Decks

• Cost: Higher upfront cost, but less maintenance required.
• Durability: Lasts 20-30 years. Composite is a mix of wood fibers and plastic, making it resistant to rot, insects, and moisture.
• Maintenance: It is low-maintenance. Just clean it annually with soap and water. No staining or sealing is required.
• Best Use: Ideal for homeowners who want a low-maintenance deck with a clean, modern look. Works for both floating and traditional decks.

3. PVC Decks

• Cost: Higher than composite but lasts longer.
• Durability: It lasts 25-40 years. It is also waterproof and insect-resistant, making it perfect for Jacksonville’s humid climate.
• Maintenance: Requires very little maintenance. No staining, sealing, or treatment is required.
• Best Use: PVC is suitable for both floating and traditional decks. It is best for homeowners who want a waterproof, low-maintenance deck.

4. Metal Decks (Aluminum or Steel)

• Cost: Highest upfront cost.
• Durability: Can last 50+ years. Rust-resistant, weatherproof, and fireproof.
• Maintenance: Minimal occasional cleaning required. No rot, warping, or insect damage.
• Best Use: Best for traditional decks, especially in commercial or high-traffic areas. Metal is strong enough to support heavy furniture, grills, or outdoor kitchens.

Maintenance of Floating vs Traditional Decks in Jacksonville, FL

Keeping your deck in good condition extends its lifespan and keeps it looking fresh. Maintenance needs vary based on the deck type and materials used.

Floating Deck Maintenance

• Clean Annually: Sweep leaves and debris off the deck to prevent mold or mildew buildup.
• Check Deck Blocks: Inspect deck blocks to ensure they haven’t shifted or sunk due to rain or ground movement. If any blocks have shifted, realign them to maintain a level deck surface.
• Deck Surface Cleaning: Clean the decking boards with a mild soap and water solution. Wood decks may need to be sealed or stained every 2-3 years.
• Inspect for Damage: Check for cracks, warping, or loose boards. Repair as needed to keep the deck safe.

Traditional Deck Maintenance

• Inspect the Ledger Board: Since traditional decks are attached to your home, it’s crucial to check the ledger board for signs of rot or decay.
• Check for Rot and Decay: Inspect the frame, beams, and joists for wood rot, especially if they are made of natural wood.
• Re-seal and Stain: To protect your wood deck from moisture and UV damage, reapply sealant or stain every 2-3 years.
• Clean the Deck Surface: Sweep regularly and power wash annually to remove dirt, mold, and algae.
• Inspect Railing and Stairs: Tighten bolts and screws on railings and stairs to ensure everything remains secure.

Comparison of Maintenance for Floating and Traditional Decks

Which is Better for Jacksonville, FL? Floating Decks or Traditional Decks?

Both floating decks and traditional decks have benefits, but which one is best depends on your needs, budget, and goals. Here’s a simple breakdown of which option might suit you better.

Choose a Floating Deck if You Want:

• Faster Installation: A floating deck can be installed in days, not weeks.
• Lower Cost: No permits, fewer materials, and less labor are required.
• DIY Possibilities: If you want to build it yourself, a floating deck is easier to handle.
• Flexibility in Location: Place it anywhere in your yard without the need to attach it to a house.
• Minimal Maintenance: No ledger boards, footings, or railings to maintain.

Choose a Traditional Deck if You Want:

• Increased Property Value: The attached decks are considered permanent home additions.
• Elevated Views: Traditional decks can be built at a higher level for better views.
• Heavier Load Capacity: Supports hot tubs, outdoor kitchens, and large furniture.
• Custom Designs: Create multi-level decks, add staircases, and build-in seating areas.
• Durability & Stability: Traditional decks are more stable because they’re attached to the house with ledger boards and supported by concrete footings.