Ipe vs. Pressure-Treated: Which Decking Material Is Best for Pergolas in Jacksonville?
If you’re planning to build a pergola in Jacksonville, you already know that the Florida climate doesn’t treat wood kindly. Between sun, rain, and humidity, the material you choose will directly impact how long your structure lasts and how much upkeep it’ll need.
The most common debate comes down to Ipe vs. pressure-treated wood. Both are solid choices, but for very different reasons. Ipe is a high-end, tropical hardwood renowned for its unmatched durability. Pressure-treated wood is more affordable, easier to work with, and still built to handle Florida weather.
Stop Dreaming.
Start Building Today!
So which one’s right for your pergola? Let’s take a closer look.
1. Florida Climate: What Your Pergola Needs to Handle
Pergolas in Jacksonville are constantly exposed to sun, salt air, and seasonal storms. That means your wood needs to withstand the elements without deteriorating in a few years.
Choosing the right material begins with its ability to withstand Florida’s most intense weather conditions, including humidity and hurricanes.
How Ipe Performs in Florida
Ipe wood has a reputation for toughness. It’s incredibly dense, which makes it naturally resistant to rot, mold, termites, and even fire. That’s why it’s often used in luxury decks and public boardwalks. In coastal climates like Jacksonville, Ipe can last 30 to 40 years, even longer if it’s sealed occasionally.
One thing to keep in mind is that to maintain Ipe’s rich, dark color, it needs to be oiled once or twice a year. Otherwise, it will fade to a soft gray. It still holds up structurally, but its appearance has changed.
What to Expect from Pressure-Treated Wood
Pressure-treated wood is the most common choice for pergolas in Florida, particularly when budget is a concern. It’s chemically treated to resist insects and moisture and holds up well in humid conditions. At Coastal Outdoor Construction, we use marine-grade pressure-treated pine for many of our pergolas and shade structures because it’s built to withstand the rigors of coastal zones.
It won’t last as long as Ipe, and you may notice minor issues, such as cracking or cupping, over time. However, with proper sealing, pressure-treated wood can still serve you well for over a decade.
2. Workability, Installation, and Upkeep
Some materials are easier to install than others, particularly in terms of cutting, fastening, and finishing. Your choice here will affect both your budget and your construction timeline.
Let’s take a look at how Ipe and pressure-treated wood compare when it’s time to build.
Building with Ipe
Installing Ipe isn’t simple. It’s so dense that it needs special blades, pre-drilling, and stainless steel fasteners. That adds time, labor costs, and complexity. Not every contractor is comfortable working with Ipe, and many Jacksonville homeowners opt for composite materials like Trex or MoistureShield if they want a premium product that’s easier to manage.
That said, Ipe offers a bold, high-end look that can elevate the overall design if your budget allows.
Pressure-Treated Wood: Easier from Start to Finish
Pressure-treated wood is easier on both the budget and the tools. It’s more flexible for custom designs and quicker to install. That’s why Coastal Outdoor Construction uses this material most often for pergolas, pavilions, and cabanas in Northeast Florida.
You’ll want to re-seal it every year or two, especially in direct sunlight or near the coast. However, overall, it’s a dependable choice that strikes a good balance between performance and price.
3. Cost Breakdown: Upfront Price vs. Long-Term Value
Decking and pergola materials come at different price points depending on your goals. For some, cost is the deciding factor. For others, it’s all about what lasts the longest.
Understanding what you’re really paying for upfront and over time is key to making the right choice.
Ipe: Premium Price, Long-Term Investment
Ipe is one of the most expensive woods available for outdoor projects. Material costs are high, and installation can be even higher due to the labor involved. In Jacksonville, you may pay two to three times more for an Ipe pergola compared to a pressure-treated wood one.
However, if you’re building your forever home or want something that will last for decades, Ipe can justify the upfront cost. It’s strong, beautiful, and practically maintenance-free if you’re okay with letting it weather naturally.
Pressure-Treated: Lower Cost, More Upkeep
Pressure-treated wood is far more affordable, both in terms of material and labor. If you’re working with a tighter budget or want to prioritize other backyard features, such as a deck or outdoor kitchen, this is a smart way to save without sacrificing structural quality.
You’ll need to budget for sealing and occasional repairs over the years, which can slowly add to the cost.
4. Appearance and Design Aesthetics
A pergola isn’t just a structure; it’s part of your home’s outdoor design. The visual style and natural beauty of the material you choose can define the overall look of your space.
Both Ipe and pressure-treated wood offer distinct aesthetics that appeal to different tastes.
Ipe: Naturally Beautiful
One of the primary reasons homeowners choose Ipe is its rich, deep color and natural grain pattern. It brings a level of visual luxury that’s hard to replicate. A freshly oiled Ipe pergola has a warm, elegant tone that complements modern patios, high-end pools, and designer landscapes.
Even when it fades to gray, the wood retains its clean and sophisticated appearance, making it perfect for homeowners who desire a timeless appeal without the need for constant upkeep.
Pressure-Treated: Simple and Versatile
While it doesn’t have the wow factor of Ipe, pressure-treated wood still looks great when stained or painted. It’s easy to customize and fits well with both classic and coastal design styles. It’s convenient if your pergola is part of a larger structure, such as a deck built with the same wood.
5. Which Material Makes Sense for Jacksonville?
Every homeowner has different needs. Some want high-end style and low maintenance, while others are more focused on saving money or building quickly.
Choosing between Ipe and pressure-treated wood comes down to your plans, budget, and the desired lifespan of your pergola.
If you’re looking for low maintenance, long-term value, and a pergola that will withstand Florida’s climate with style, Ipe is the better option, especially if you’re investing in a premium outdoor space.
If affordability and flexibility are more important right now, pressure-treated wood still offers durability and a wide range of design options. It’s the most common choice in Northeast Florida for good reason.
At Coastal Outdoor Construction, we help you weigh these decisions based on your specific layout and needs. Whether you’re leaning toward Ipe, pressure-treated wood, or exploring other materials, our team will guide you through it.
Get a free estimate and let’s start designing your pergola today.
FAQs
Ipe is more durable, resistant to insects and rot, and offers a longer lifespan than pressure-treated wood. It’s a premium material that performs better in the long term, especially in Jacksonville’s climate.
The main disadvantages are cost and installation complexity. Ipe is very dense, requiring specialized tools, longer labor time, and a higher upfront budget.
Ipe can last 30 to 40 years or more, even in coastal areas. With minimal upkeep, it remains structurally sound for decades and naturally resists pests and decay.
Pressure-treated wood requires regular maintenance to prevent warping, cracking, and mold growth. If not sealed regularly, it can deteriorate more quickly in Florida’s humid environment.
Ipe is one of the longest-lasting natural materials. However, composite brands like Trex and MoistureShield can also last 25 to 50 years with little to no maintenance.
Written By:
Coastal Outdoor Construction
Let's Talk About Your Decking Project
After we get some information from you, we’ll set up a time to discuss your project in further detail.
